OUR VERDICT
SoFi wins on APY with direct deposit (4.60% vs 4.35%). Ally wins on features and banking experience — better app, more products, and no direct deposit requirement.
Advertiser Disclosure: WiseIQ earns a commission when you apply through links on this page. This does not influence our rankings. See how we rank →
Unique advantage: 4.60% APY with direct deposit — one of the highest rates available
✓ Pros
✗ Cons
Unique advantage: 4.35% APY with no conditions — no direct deposit requirement
✓ Pros
✗ Cons
| Feature | SoFi Checking & Savings | Ally Bank High Yield Savings |
|---|---|---|
| APY | 4.60% (with DD) / 1.20% (without) | 4.35% (no conditions) |
| Minimum Balance | None | None |
| Monthly Fee | None | None |
| Direct Deposit Required | For 4.60% APY | No |
| ATM Access | Limited | 60,000+ ATMs |
| Mobile App Rating | 4.8/5 (iOS) | 4.7/5 (iOS) |
| Savings Buckets | No | Yes |
| Early Direct Deposit | Yes (2 days) | No |
| FDIC Insured | Yes | Yes |
SoFi is best for people who can set up direct deposit — the 4.60% APY is one of the highest available and the early deposit feature is a nice bonus.
Ally is best for people who can't or don't want to set up direct deposit, or who want a more established bank with better ATM access.
Is SoFi or Ally better for savings?
SoFi offers a higher APY (4.60%) but requires direct deposit. Ally offers 4.35% with no conditions. If you can set up direct deposit to SoFi, it wins on rate. If you want no strings attached, Ally is the better choice. On $50,000, the difference is $125/year.
Does SoFi require direct deposit for the high APY?
Yes. SoFi's 4.60% APY requires setting up direct deposit. Without direct deposit, the APY drops to 1.20%. Direct deposit can be from an employer, government benefits, or other recurring income sources.
Is SoFi Bank safe?
Yes. SoFi Bank is FDIC insured up to $250,000 per depositor. SoFi received its bank charter in 2022 and is regulated by the OCC (Office of the Comptroller of the Currency). It's a legitimate, regulated bank.